The Official “Unofficial” Luigi Mangione Timeline

The following timeline is a list of both “official” and “unofficial” events that may be relevant to the arrest and trial of Luigi Mangione, accused of shooting and killing UnitedHealthCare CEO, Brian Thompson. The “official” timeline consists of things reported by a“officials” in the case such as main stream media, local or federal law enforcement, lawyers or anyone acting in an “official” capacity. The “unofficial” timeline contains rumors and potentially related information that has not “officially” been accepted as relevant but may cast doubt upon the “official” story. Unofficial does not necessarily mean unverifiable. It merely means it is not officially part of the narrative. Unofficial entries are listed in yellow font.

Summary of Our Position: While we do not rule out the possibility that Luigi Mangione is responsible and the “lone gunman”, our lead analyst sees reasons to suspect there are multiple conspirators and that Luigi was likely just one of a group of individuals that planned to pull it off. In this theory, Luigi Mangione may have purposefully played a diversion to allow the actual shooter to get away. Among some of the reasons for this theory is that the shooter knew exactly where to go to get off camera for a considerable amount of time in Central Park and that the suspect later seen leaving the park was dressed similarly but not identically. Is it possible this is a look alike? Several key pieces of evidence feel deliberately placed to mislead law enforcement. In addition it makes little sense as to why the shooter would take steps to hide their identity, go on the run for five days, and then simply get caught at a McDonalds with the same clothes, backpack, weapon, and a letter confessing to the whole thing while declaring he acted alone. One additional theory that we are exploring is the money trail. Brian Thompson, as well as other UnitedHealth execs, were under investigation by the Department of Justice and scheduled to appear to testify. There is a huge amount of money at stake leading to the possibility that this was a profession hit. Even if Luigi turns out to be the actual shooter and lone gunman, there is the bigger social question to ask. Was the shooters actions “justified” in any way? Was this the case of the little guy fighting against corporate greed? Is UnitedHealth guilty of far more “murders” by denying claims that this one act against a CEO?

2004

  • Brian Thompson starts working for UnitedHealCare in a relatively low-level job. He slowly raised through the ranks and eventually became CEO of UnitedHealthcare some time in 2019. (Source: Tubitv)

2010

  • Jay M. Feinman publishes a book examining the insurance industry’s practices, highlighting how companies may delay, deny, or defend against paying out claims to policyholders. It is titled “Delay, Deny, Defend: Why Insurance Companies Don’t Pay Claims and What You Can Do About It”

2016

  • In 2016, Luigi Mangione delivered a valedictorian speech at his high school, the Gilman School, an all-boys preparatory school in Baltimore, Maryland.

  • Mangione’s now-deleted Reddit account first appeared in 2016 under the username “Mister_Cactus.” The user posted on a subreddit multiple times about spondylolisthesis, a condition where a bone slips out of alignment, putting pressure on nerves around the spine and lower vertebrae. (Source: The Daily Pennsylvanian)

2019

  • United Healthcare Post-Acute Care Denials for Medicare Advantage are 8.7%. By 2024 that number would skyrocket to 22.7% denials. (Source: Tubitv)

2020

  • Luigi Mangione worked remotely as a data engineer for TrueCar, a Santa Monica-based company, from November 2020 until some point in 2023. (Source: Wikipedia)

December

  • Luigi Mangion graduates from University of Pennsylvania. (Source: Tubitv)

  • Mangione graduated from Penn in 2020 with a bachelor’s and master’s degree in computer and information science after four years and was inducted into Penn's Eta Kappa Nu honor society for excellence in electrical and computer engineering. (Source: The Daily Pennsylvanian)

December 21, 2020

  • Dane Elkins, age 21 at the time, calls 911 from a roadside in California (near Bakersfield) in apparent distress. When authorities arrive, his car is found on the side of the road with a flat tire. Dane is missing but his phone and wallet are still in the vehicle.

    • His car, a 2017 gray Honda Civic, was found abandoned near Interstate 5 and Templin Highway in Castaic, California.

    • He was reportedly driving along the California coast in the days leading up to his disappearance.

    • Dane had been traveling between cities such as Santa Cruz, Salinas, and possibly passing through areas like San Francisco before heading south toward Castaic.

    • To this day Dane remains missing and the circumstances around his disappearance are unanswered. Before his disappearance, Dane informed his family that he believed he was being recruited by the CIA and that he was not going to accept. He claimed that he feared for his own life and that of his family. Four years later, “credible” sources indicate that Dane has been seen by close friends but his whereabouts are still unknown.

    • WHY DOES IT MATTER: Online, rumors begin to circulate that Dan Elkins could be the shooter of Brian Thompson, CEO of UnitedHealthCare though there has been no credible reason to believe this theory that I have seen to date. Having said that, the physical similarities between Dane and Luigi are numerous including the approximate age (both 25-26 at the time), their height 5’10 to 5’11, their build (both physically fit), as well as similar facial structure and eyebrows. To date there is no “credible” evidence linking Dane Elkins to being in New York (or anywhere for that matter) but rumors continue to circulate in social media circles.

    • It is simply odd that Luigi Mangioni was working for a California company with an office in San Francisco around the time that Dane Elkins went missing and may have passed through San Francisco. This of course means nothing in and of itself other than to say it’s a strange coincidence that people believe Dane is involved and the two theoretically were in the same general area at the same time.

2021

April

  • Brian Thompson is named CEO of UnitedHealthcare in April 2021.

  • Adreas Malm publishes a non-fiction book titled “How to Blow Up a Pipeline” which focuses on a group of individuals who conspire to sabotage and oil pipeline as a form of protest against ecological destruction. The book was made into a movie in 2022 and directed by Daniel Goldhaber. (Source: Wikipedia)

December

December 21, 2021

  • Nancy Pelosi, the former Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, purchased call options for Palo Alto Networks (PANW) valued at $1.24 million on December 21, 2021. These options had a strike price of $500 and an expiration date of September 16, 2022. This transaction was disclosed in a periodic transaction report filed on January 10, 2022. (Source: The Motley Fool)

2022

  • A movie adaptation of the book “How to Blow Up a Pipeline” is released, directed by Daniel Goldhabor. (Source: Wikipedia)

    • NOTE: Those who believe that there may be a group of conspirators involved in the UnitedHealthCare shooting have claimed that the whole thing reminds them of this move. I have not seen the movie yet.

  • Brian Thompson’s salary is reported at $9,102,852 in 2022. At the same time his salary is increasing, UnitedHealthCare’s denials of claims are going “through the roof”.(Source: Tubitv)

  • Luigi Mangione is allegedly living in Hawaii at an “all adult dorm”. (Source: Tubitv)

    • NOTE: I almost get the impression from the way they say it that the “dorm” was some sort of swingers dorm or commune for young 20-30 years olds. That’s pure speculation from the way it was reported with a pause “for lack of a better way to describe it, an all adult dorm”. (Source: Tubitv)

  • Luigi helped form a book club at this “adult dorm”. (Source: Tubitv)

  • While living in Hawaii Luigi signed up for surfing lessons and had a wipe out that exasberated a previous back injury he already had. (Source: Tubitv).

  • Luigi spend about a week in bed according to friends. (Source: Tubitv)

  • Luigi posted images of pins in his back on Twitter and said that the pain was so bad that he couldn’t even have sex and prevented him from physical activity. (Source: Tubitv)

  • The New York Post documentary described Luigi as starting to withdraw from friends and becoming more isolated and despondent about his physical health. (Source: Tubitv)

April

  • The People’s Action Institute says it launched a campaign in 2022 to fight back against coverage denials by health insurers. After the protest at Optum headquarters in April, critics met with UnitedHealthcare executives, pushing to help individual patients and for broader reforms at the company. The People’s Action Institute would later organize at least two protests outside UnitedHealthCare’s headquarters in 2024 in April and July and carried a wooden casket stating that UnitedHealth Care Denies Claims. (source: StarTribune)

2023

JULY

  • A July 2023 post indicated an injury flare-up around the region after “Mister_Cactus” had gone surfing, while other posts suggest the user had spinal fusion surgery around the same time. Medical professionals point to surgery as a last-resort option for patients like Mangione. (Source: The Daily Pennsylvanian)

August

  • “Surgery was painful for the first couple days, but I was shocked that, by day seven, I was on literally zero pain meds,” Mangione posted on Reddit in August 2023. “Obviously will be awhile until I get into rigorous activity, but it was way less of a big deal than I had anticipated.” (Source: The Daily Pennsylvanian)

October

  • The Department of Justice begins an investigation beginning in October 2023, focused on potential antitrust violations related to UnitedHealth’s acquisitions and business practices. The public disclosure of this probe was made in late February 2024 resulting in a notable decline in UnitedHealth’s stock value, impacting shareholders. (Source: Insurance Newsnet)

    • It’s important to note that while the lawsuit accuses Thompson of insider trading, these allegations are part of ongoing legal proceedings and have not been adjudicated. Thompson was tragically killed in December 2024, and investigations into both his death and the insider trading allegations are ongoing. (Source: NewYork Post)

  • The Hollywood Firefighter Pension group files a lawsuit alleging Insider Trading by United Health Execs. (Source: Tubitv)

2024

February

February 12, 2024

  • Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi reported two purchases of call options for Palo Alto Networks (PANW).

    • She acquired 50 call options with a strike price of $200 and an expiration date of January 17, 2025. The investment is valued between $500,000 and $1 million dollars. (Source: CapitalTrades.com).

      • Call options provide the right, but not the obligation, to buy a stock at a predetermined price before a specified expiration date.

      • NOTE: Why is this important? If Nancy Pelosi has inside information that the stock price of Palo Alto Networks is about to go up, she can buy the stock at the lower price even after the stock price suddenly skyrockets.

February 16, 2024

According to to a class-action lawsuit filed by the City of Hollywood Firefighters Pension Fund, Brian Thompson, CEO of UnitedHealthCare sold over $15 million worth of his personal shares on February 16, 2024, just before a Department of Justice probe became public, leading to a significant drop in the company’s stock price.

February 21, 2024

  • United Healthcare hacked in massive ransomware data breach effecting it’s Change Healthcore (CHC) unit. This breach impacted 100 MILLION customers and gave hackers access to users sensitive personal information including names, addresses, social security numbers and healhcare records. (Source: UnitedHealthGroup.com)

  • The data breach caused widespread disruptions of services across the United States including a slow down of processing claims.

  • Healthcare providers reported substantial losses of revunue with some estimates being as high as 100 million in losses per day.

  • United Health Group (parent company of UnitedHealthCare) reported $872 million in losses in the first quarter of 2024 due to the attack.

  • United Health paid $22 million in rasom to the attackers to regain access to their systems.

  • The group responsible for the attack was identified as ALPHV/BlackCat group.

  • In response to this events, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services proposed new cybersecurity regulations for healthcare organizations. (Source: TheVerge, Reuters, Wall Street Journal )

  • NOTE: Why is this important? It is a possible motive for the killing of UnitedHealthCare CEO, Brian Thompson. Some have suggested that Brian Thompson was killed by the powerful healthcare industry who lost nearly a billion dollars in revenue over the attack suggesting that because it happened under his leadership, someone had to pay. Others have suggested that this event set of a complex chain reaction of things that led to the eventual assassination of Brian Thompson.

  • Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi purchases an additional 20 call options with the same strike price an expiration date as the purchase on February 12th. This investment is valued at $100,00 to $250,000. (Source: CapitalTrades.com). These transactions are disclosed in accordance with the STOCK Act which mandates that members of congress report securities transactions within 45 days.

  • Paulo Alto Networks was hired to assist with the cybersecurity hack on UnitedHealthCare. This group included experts from Palo Alto Networks, Mandiant, Google, Microsoft, Cisco, and Amazon. This team was on-site at Change HealthCare’s Nashville Central Command Operations Center on February 21 and collaborated to rebuld the companies technology infrastructure, to enhance security and restore critical services.

April

  • Brian Thompson was stationed at UnitedHealth’s headquarters in Minnesota when over 100 protesters descended on the campus and marched around carrying a casket with the words “UnitedHealth Denies Care”. The protesters were organized by the People's Action Institute and were calling UnitedHealth practices an “epidemic” of denying care. (source: NewYork Post)

May

May 14, 2024

  • In May 2024, the City of Hollywood Firefighters’ Pension Fund filed a class-action lawsuit against UnitedHealth Group executives, including CEO Brian Thompson, alleging insider trading. Also named in the lawsuit was UnitedHealth Group CEO, Andrew Witty and Executive Chairman Stephen Hemsley. The lawsuit claims that these executives sold substantial amounts of their personally held UnitedHealth shares while concealing a Department of Justice (DOJ) antitrust investigation into the company. Specifically, it alleges that Thompson sold over $15 million worth of his shares on February 16, 2024, just before the DOJ’s probe became public, leading to a significant drop in the company’s stock price. The investigation was not disclosed until January 27, 2024. Source: HealthcareFinance, and Justia Dockets and Filings)

  • The pension fund claims that the executives’ actions violated federal securities laws, resulting in financial losses for shareholders. The lawsuit seeks compensatory damages for the affected investors. (Source: Planadvisor)

  • (

June/July?

  • 6 months before the shooting: Luigi Mangione was traveling through Asia and sharing his experiences on social media. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder, S1E1)

  • Luigi is described as having “gone dark” and friends were posting on social media trying to contact him as of July 9th (Source: Tubitv)

  • Luigi’s mother claimed that she lost contact with her son in July of 2024 but didn’t report it to San Francisco Police Department until November 2024.

  • Luigi reportedly posted a comment about his travels online.

“There is a very real sense of traveling as an adventurer rather than as a tourist. So I’m here in the mountains in Nara, and it’s f***ing beautiful, man. I think I want to stay here for like a month. And just meditate, and just hot spring, and do some writing. I want some time to zen out.” – Luigi Mangione (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • In another protest organized by the People's Action Institute in July 2024 at UnitedHealth Group's Minnetonka headquarters, 11 individuals were arrested for blocking a public street. According to Minnetonka police, three of those arrested were from Minnesota, while the others hailed from Illinois, Maine, New York, Texas, and West Virginia. Specific names of the arrested individuals were not publicly disclosed. Like the protest in April the protesters carried a casket around claiming UnitedHealth Denies Claims. (Source: StarTribune)

August

  • On August 15th, Mangione had allegedly written in his diary, “The details are finally coming together. I’m glad in a way that I procrastinated, because it allowed me to learn more about UnitedHealthCare (SOURCE: TMZ Documentary, Luigi Mangione: The Mind of a Killer)

October

  • October 22nd it was assumed that Mangione had set his sights on UnitedHealthCare CEO, Brian Thompson. He allegedly wrote in his diary that he intended to “wack” the CEO at an investor conference a the Hilton in Mid-town Manhatten. (SOURCE: TMZ Documentary, Luigi Mangione: The Mind of a Killer)

November

  • Shortly before the event, Mangione spent a few nights at the Green Tortoise Hotel in San Fransisco.  He partied with guests and told them his name was Mark Rasario from New Jersey. Date unknown (SOURCE: TMZ Documentary, Luigi Mangione: The Mind of a Killer)

November 18, 2024

  • Mangione’s mother filed a missing persons report in San Francisco in November, seeking information about her son, according to two law enforcement sources. (Source: ABCNews)

  • Her son Luigi had been working for a company called TrueCar in their San Francisco office. Truecar, however, claimed Mangione had not been employed there since 2023. (Source: KRON4 News)

  • In the missing person report filed with SFPD, Mangione’s mother expressed concern after losing contact with him since July 2024. She believed he was residing and working in San Francisco at the time. (Source: San Francisco Standard)

November 24, 2024

  • 10:11 PM: the suspect arrived at the Port Authority Bus Terminal on 42nd Street after taking a Greyhound bus that originated in Atlanta, Georgia. (Source: CBSNews)

    • The bus originated in Atlanta and made six or seven stops on the way to New York. Police could not immediately determine where he got on the bus. (Source: APNews)

  • Joseph Kenny, the Police Department’s chief of detectives, said the gunman is believed to have arrived in New York on Nov. 24 on a bus that originated in Atlanta, and police believe he left the city on a bus after the shooting. (Source: CBSNews)

  • The suspect in the shooting entered New York City by bus on Nov. 24, when a surveillance camera at Port Authority Bus Terminal caught his arrival at 9 p.m., law enforcement sources told ABC News. (Source: ABCNews)

    • NOTE: ABCNews reports that the suspect arrived at 9pm and CBSNews reports he arrived at 10:11 PM. Not sure what the discrepancy is.

  • The inbound bus originated in Atlanta but it was not immediately clear where the suspect boarded. (Source: ABCNews)

  • ~11:00 PM: The suspect took a cab to the area of the New York Hilton Midtown and spent about half an hour walking in the area of the hotel until around 11 p.m according to CBSNews. The official sealed complaint by the FBI states he was there about an hour. (Source: CBSNews, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

    • That evening he allegedly “CASED” the Hilton hotel”. He knew the investor conference would be taking place there in a week and a half and Brian Thompson would be front and center (SOURCE: TMZ Documentary, Luigi Mangione: The Mind of a Killer)

  • The suspect then took another cab and checked into a hostel on New York City’s Upper West Side that day and later checked out, sources said. (Source: ABCNews, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

The suspect then checked into the Hi New York City Hostel on Amsterdam Avenue on the Upper West Side. He used fake identification and lowered his mask to speak to the clerk, police say, the only time he lowered his mask in the hostel. After this, he avoided conversation and hid his face. The FBI on Friday described the man pictured as the “unknown suspect” wanted for the killing of Thompson. (Source: CBSNews)

  • The suspect takes a taxi to the HI New York City Hostel at 891 Amsterdam Ave., where he stays until the morning of the shooting. It was listed in the TMZ special as being the “American Youth Hostels”. He presents an ID that police believe to be fake. Two roommates in a shared room that had bunkbeds and claimed they never saw his face, police said, because he kept his mask on. (Source: APNews, TMZ Documentary, Luigi Mangione: The Mind of a Killer)

    • NOTE: THIS IS HUGE. I have a theory that the suspect had at least one accomplice. Many say two or more. This report from APNews and CBSNews confirms that the suspect had two roomates with him for days. WHO WERE THEY???? I don’t buy that the suspect hid his face from the roommates for days.. Did the suspect have accomplices???

    • NOTE: The original 911 call that came in about the shooter said he had a light brown or cream colored jacket and black gloves. This description of a light brown or cream jacket was repeated by the NYPD later the same day in a press conference even though the video suggests the jacket is dark gray. In the two images below it appears that one image has been color corrected or shifted to make the jacket appear light brown or cream in one photo and black in the other which conveniently “fixes” the conflicting information. Is this merely a trick of the lighting or a deliberate color correction to line up with the stated eyewitness testimony?

November 29, 2024

  • The suspect was checked out of the hostel, but police say they believe it was an administrative checkout because the suspect did not appear at the required time. The suspect then checked back in. Police said he didn’t leave the hostel in the days before the shooting and he did not speak to anyone. He had two roommates. (Source: CBSNews)

    • The man was checked out of the hostel, where guests are automatically checked out if they don’t show at the desk by a certain time. Police don’t believe he stayed someplace else and checked back into the same hostel the next day. (Source: APNews)

November 30, 2024

  • The suspect likely checked back into the HI New York City Hostel on the Upper West Side on Nov. 30, sources said. (Source: ABCNews)

  • NOTE: The explanation for why the suspect checked out and back in seems to be explained by the statement that the checkout system is automatic if you don’t show up. It appears the suspect planned to stay longer but missed a check in period and thus was auto checked out. One might ask, where was the suspect when they missed checking in to remain checked in?

  • The following photos were attributed by ABC on their website (Source: ABCNews)

    • Note: The backpack in the set of photos above have black straps and in the other set of photos below have gray straps. Also the jackets are not the same. Note the differences in pockets and zippers. Did the suspect change jackets or have more than one jacket?

  • Many “unofficial” experts have done analysis on the photos below compared to Luigi Mangione, now the official suspect and have concluded that this man is not the same man as Luigi.

  • “Officially”, however, this is Luigi Mangioni

December

December 2, 2024

Brian Thompson arrives in New York City from Minnesota, where he lived. He was scheduled to speak at the investors’ conference Wednesday morning. (Source: CBSNews)

December 4, 2024 (Wednesday)

  • 5:00 AM: Police say the gunman was seen on surveillance video around 5 a.m. local time near the Frederick Douglass Houses, a NYCHA complex on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. (Source: CBSNews)

  • ~5:30 AM – The suspect leaves a hostel on the Upper West Side of Manhattan at 104th Street and Amsterdam Avenue at 5:30 AM. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder).

    • The time was also listed by ABC on their website as being more precisely 5:34 am (Source: ABCNews)

  • ~5:35 AM - the Shooter left the Hostel wearing the Gray Backpack and rode an electric bicycle down Central Park West to a location near the Midtown Hotel (Source: Complaint Southern District of New York: United States vs Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

  • NOTE: In the top image above it appears as if the suspect may be carrying a battery for the e-bike. If so, this may explain how the suspect planned to ensure that the bike was available for a get away and not taken by another user.

~5:41 AM: the suspect arrived at the New York Hilton Midtown and began walking around the area. Police say it’s possible he biked down because it took around 10 minutes. While walking around he purchased items from a nearby coffee shop and “returned to a bench”. (Source: Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione).

NOTE: It has been widely debated whether or not the suspect could have made the trip from the Hostel as the official complain says to the Hilton in Midtown in six minutes. Sources such as Brian O’Shea’s substack page document the distances on maps as well as publicly available information about the speed of many ebikes and suggests the trip is nearly impossible to make in the time suggested. Others who claim to live in New York have stated it can be done and have attempted to prove it. I have been reluctant to weigh in on whether or not it CAN be done but I recommend you look at Brian O’Shea’s analysis for the argument that it likely can’t be done as stated in the complaint (SOURCE: Brian O’Shea’s substack)

NOTE: It is presumed, though not mentioned here, that the items purchased were a Kind bar and a bottle of water.

  • 6:15 AM: Approximately 30 minutes before the shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson on December 4, 2024, surveillance footage captured an individual matching the suspect’s description purchasing a bottle of water and a KIND bar at a Starbucks at 1290 Sixth Avenue in Midtown Manhattan.

    • Thompson, a 50-year-old father of two, was in New York City for an investors’ conference (Source: CBSNews)

    • The suspect is believed to have dropped this same wrapper and water bottle with his DNA either AT the Starbucks or “NEAR the crime scene” but the precise location has not been disclosed. Numerous sources say it was found “near” but not “at” the crime scene. (Source: NBCMiami)

  • 6:17 AM:, the suspect was seen at a Starbucks near the hotel, where a law enforcement source says he paid cash. Sources say surveillance images may have captured enough of his face to run through facial recognition, and investigators are running forensic tests on a water bottle and candy bar wrapper they believe the suspect left behind. (Source: CBSNews)

  • 6:19 AM: Cleared CCTV video shows a man who appears to be the suspect walking west on 55th Street at 6:19 a.m. The video shows him stoop down as he appears to momentarily drop an object on the garbage before continuing to walk. (Source: ABCNews)

    • Note: I am still looking to confirm WHAT was dropped. Was it the water bottle and Kind bar wrapper? If so, how “near” to the crime scene is this?

  • 6:29 AM: The suspect appeared to walk past a parking lot on West 54th Street at 6:29 a.m and is seen on a cell phone. — across the street some 50 meters from the site of the shooting. (Source: ABCNews, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

    • NOTE: The official sources say the call seen here is 6:29 AM however the time stamp on the photo clearly lists 7:29 AM. I am going to give the time stamp benefit of the doubt and say it’s a matter of daylight savings time discrepancy but it’s interesting to note the time difference and should be investigated.

    • NOTE: In addition, Brian O’Shea lists on his substack page why he believes the cell phone image is actually taken in a different location than officially reported and documents how he knows that to be true. See his page: https://brianoshea.substack.com/p/examination-of-the-unsealed-federal

  • 6:30 AM: Surveillance video obtained by The New York Times shows the suspect talking on a cellphone around 6:30 a.m. while walking toward the hotel. (Source: CBSNews)

  • 6:38 AM: From 6:38 a.m. to 6:44 a.m., the masked gunman stood against a wall on the north side of West 54th Street across from the New York Hilton Midtown, prosecutors said. (Source: ABCNews)

  • 6:39 AM: police say the gunman arrived outside the hotel on foot. (Source: CBSNews)

  • 6:44 AM: Brian Thompson walks from his hotel across the street to the Hilton where the shareholder meeting will take place. (Source: CBSNews)

    • 6:44 AM: Brian Thompson, CEO of UnitedHealthcare, is seen walking down the block from his hotel to the Hilton on 6th Avenue. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

    • Philip Klein, whose security firm previously provided bodyguard services for Brian Thompson, expressed surprise that Thompson was unaccompanied by security at the time of his death. Klein noted, "It was normal operation for that company that they would have their own private security team to take care of their corporate executives." (Source: NewYork Post)

    • NOTE: The Federal complaint against Mangione states that the suspect had been waiting for Brian Thompson for about an hour before following him across the street. What is interesting to us is that the suspect apparently wasn’t worried about missing his opportunity when going to buy items at a nearby coffee shop thus suggesting the suspect wasn’t concerned about missing him. Also the phone cell call is interesting. Who is the suspect talking to? Was he made aware that he had time to kill. (Source: Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione).

  • The Hilton’s Midtown Hotel is located on Sixth Avenue between West 54th and 55th streets. (Source: CBSNews)

  • 6:46 AM : A deadly shooting occurs in Midtown Manhattan. Brian Thompson is shot outside the Hilton on 6th Avenue. The shooting is caught on surveillance camera. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder, CBSNews))

    • “Also at the scene, and at the time of the shooting, there appeared to be a woman smoking a cigarette and holding a large coffee cup (similar to a “Venti” sized take away cup one might get at a Starbucks) who fled the scene after the second round was fired but did not drop her coffee even as she fled.” (SOURCE: https://brianoshea.substack.com/p/examination-of-the-unsealed-federal)

    • “There was also a black SUV parked two cars up from a delivery truck that illuminated its lights almost at the very moment Brian Thompson came into view. As soon as the shooter fired his last shot and Brian Thompson appeared to fall to the ground, the shooter glanced to his right (in the direction of the now slain Brian Thompson), then to his left where he appear to look directly at the SUV or its driver as the shooter moved toward the left side of the sidewalk. The shooter then crossed in front of this SUV and fled across West 54th street towards 6 1/2 Avenue.” (SOURCE: https://brianoshea.substack.com/p/examination-of-the-unsealed-federal)

    • Officers respond to a 911 call of a person shot in front of the Hilton hotel located at 1335 Avenue of the Americas, according to Kenny. (Source: Newsweek)

    • Police said this is when an assassin wearing a dark hoodie and gray backpack stepped from behind a parked car in the predawn darkness, before pursuing Thompson for a few steps and shooting him with a 9-millimeter pistol. (Source: Newsweek)

    • The masked gunman fatally shot Thompson in front of the north entrance to the Hilton, police said. (Source: ABCNews)

    • “The shooter then walks toward the victim and continues to shoot,” NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny said. “It appears that the gun malfunctions, as he clears the jam and begins to fire again.” (Source: ABCNews)

    • According to CCTV footage, the gun appeared to jam after every shot, with the shooter reloading the weapon. The footage also shows that the suspect continued to shoot at Thompson as he fell to the ground. Kenny, the chief of detectives for the NYPD, declined to say when asked whether he believed the killer was a professional. But he noted the apparent ease with which he cleared a jam while firing the pistol. “It does seem he’s proficient in the use of firearms,” Kenny said. (Source: Newsweek)

  • The shooter fires three times. It seems the gun jammed several times in between the shots. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • The shots struck Brian Thompson in the back and leg. (Source: CBSNews)

  • He was struck at least once in the back and at least once in the right calf. (Source: Newsweek)

  • UnitedHealthcare told CBS News the shooting took place during the company’s annual investor relations conference. It was scheduled to be livestreamed starting at 8 a.m. local time, roughly an hour and 15 minutes after Thompson was shot. (Source: CBSNews)

  • It was later reported that the shell casings had messages on them, words that were written on. each one. “Delay. Deny. Depose”. Handwritten with a permanent marker. This is believed to be a reference to the book Jay M. Feinman published in 2010 examining the insurance industry’s practices titled “Delay, Deny, Defend: Why Insurance Companies Don’t Pay Claims and What You Can Do About It” (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

    • The New York Post reporter, Caitlin McCormack says that the words “Delay, Deny, Depose” were “carved into the shell casings which is contradictory to the permanent marker theory that some have heard reported. (Source: Tubitv)

  • The shooter runs across 54th Street, goes up Ziegfeld Alley by the Ziegfeld Theatre. He then turns on West 55th street , turns again head toward Central Park and escapes on an e-bike through Central Park. (Source: Tubitv, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione))

  • Along the way he allegedly discards a water bottle and cell phone. (Source: Tubitv)

    • Police say the suspect ran into the alley between West 54th and 5th streets, then rode a bike up Sixth Avenue to Central Park. (Source: CBSNews)

    • The suspect fled the scene shortly after the shooting, heading “northbound into an alleyway between 54th Street and 55th Street,” and walked west on Avenue of the Americas, and eventually got onto an electric bike and rode toward Central Park. Kenny said the bike had a GPS system and police are working on gathering more details from the company. (Source: Newsweek)

  • 6:48 AM: “The original 911 call that came in at about 6:48am about this murder described the shooter as wearing a “cream colored coat” and “black leather gloves” which seems to be a different description than the person pictured in the official NYPD postings and public service announcements.” (SOURCE: https://brianoshea.substack.com/p/examination-of-the-unsealed-federal)

    • NOTE: Eyewitness testimony is horrendous and it is possible that the caller simply remembers it differently than they actually saw it. These kind of mistakes are common in eyewitness testimony. However, it’s worth noting that the description if MUCH different.

  • 6:48 AM: Officers arrive at the scene and find Thompson on the sidewalk in front of the hotel with gunshot wounds to his back and leg. He was taken to the hospital by EMS.

  • 6:48 AM: Police say the suspect was last seen riding the bike on Center Drive at 6:48 a.m. (Source: CBSNews)

  • Cameras loose sight of the shooter at this point as the park is a major “blind spot” in the city. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • 6:56 AM: The alleged shooter then possibly comes out of central park at 77th on the bike and exited Central Park at 77th Street and Central Park West. After disappearing inside the park for a period of time, the Shooter was captured on video again exiting the park near West 77th Street and Central Park West riding north on Central Park West. When he emerged from the park, the Shooter was no longer carrying the Gray Backpack. (Source: ABCNews and APNews, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

NOTE: In the picture above, while the gray backpack is missing, it does appear as if there is a possible lump on the suspects back suggesting a different backpack, perhaps worn under the jacket this time.

6:58 AM: He passes another camera on 85th Street and Columbus Avenue, still on the bicycle. Security camera footage captured the Shooter riding the electric bicycle near West 85th Street and Columbus Avenue. Two minutes later, at 7 approximately 7:00 a.m., the Shooter was captured on video walking near West 86th Street and Columbus Avenue, without the electric bicycle. (Source: APNews, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

  • 7:00 AM Suspect is seen at 86th Street and Columbus Avenue, the suspect has ditched the bike and took a taxi to the Port Authority bus facility at 178th Street, by the George Washington Bridge. He is seen on 86th with no bike and no backpack. (Source: CBSNews and APNews)

    • (NOTE: the cameras lose sight of the shooter in Central Park and only later do we see what appears to be the same man exiting on the bike when it is caught on camera again. The question is, is the man exiting the park the same man as the one who entered the park?)

  • 7:04 AM: the suspect gets in a cab northbound from 86th and Amsterdam to a Port Authority bus station near the George Washington Bridge. In the cab, the suspect turns towards a camera which gets a crystal clear shot of him peering through a partition that separates the driver from the passenger. We can clearly see his distinctive eyes and his distinctive eyebrows. The suspect didn’t do anything to camouflage his appearance (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • The suspect was seen exiting the cab at 178th and Amsterdam and is seen entering the Port Authority Bus Terminal. (Source: Tubitv)

  • The theory was that the suspect boarded a Greyhound bus and that was the last contact they had with him that day. (Source: Tubitv)

    • Note: Most agree that this bears a striking resemblance to Luigi Mangioni but not the man in the first images released. Are they the same man? Some, such as myself, speculate that this “suspect” may not be the same “suspect” that committed the shooting. One theory is that Suspect 1 (the shooter) changed places with Suspect 2 (decoy) who led the authorities on a wild goose chase so suspect 1 could make a clean get away.

  • Time Unknown: At first, investigators believed Mangione then boarded a bus at that Port Authority terminal, where investigators said he was spotted on security cameras being dropped off by the taxi. But there was no imagery of Mangione actually getting onto a bus, sources said. (Source: ABCNews)

  • Note: This is a VERY interesting development. How do investigators claim that the suspect was spotted on security cameras and yet we have NO IMAGERY of it?

  • Time Unknown: Police sources told ABC News there’s video evidence that shows Mangione left the George Washington Bridge bus station, went south to Penn Station and left New York City by train to Philadelphia.

    • Note: Has ANY video of this location been released to the public? If so, where? If not, why?

  • 7:12 AM: Brian Thompson is pronounced dead at Mount Sinai West Hospital. (Source: CBSNews) Howver, Fox9.com reports that Brian Thompson is reported dead at Roosevelt Hosptial. (Source: Fox9)

    • NOTE: Why the discrepancy?

  • 7:30 AM: The suspect is seen near the George Washington Bridge and the bus terminal there. It offers commuter service to New Jersey and Greyhound routes to Philadelphia, Boston and Washington. (Source: APNews)

  • 8:00 AM: The investor conference Brian Thompson was scheduled to attend is set to begin.

  • Mangione then spent several days traversing the state from Philadelphia to Pittsburgh, according to Pennsylvania authorities. (Source: ABCNews)

  • 8:23 AM: Maple Grove police arrive at the home of Brian Thompson’s wife, Paulette Thompson, to notify her of the death. Thompson and Paulette had been living in separate homes less than a mile apart in suburban Maple Grove for several years, according to the Wall Street Journal. (Source: Newsweek)

    • News reports are claiming that Brian Thompson’s wife had told the media that Brian had received threats against him. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

    • Paulette Thompson told NBC News on Wednesday her husband had been receiving threats. “There had been some threats,” she said. “Basically, I don’t know, a lack of coverage? I don’t know details. I just know that he said there were some people that had been threatening him.” (Source: Newsweek)

    • The police departments in Maple Grove, where Thompson lived, and in Minnetonka, where UnitedHealth is based, both said they had received no complaints about threats to Thompson, according to the Wall Street Journal. (Source: Newsweek)

    • Thompson was among three United executives named in a May lawsuit filed by a Florida pension fund, alleging the company concealed a Justice Department antitrust investigation from shareholders while insiders sold stock, including $15 million worth of shares held by Thompson personally. He had not responded to the allegations in court prior to his death. (Source: Newsweek)

  • 9:00 AM: Andrew Witty, chief executive of UnitedHealth Group, UnitedHealthcare’s parent company, interrupts the proceedings at the investor conference to announce that the event was being canceled due to “a very serious medical situation with one of our team members.” (Source: Newsweek)

  • 11:30 AM: The NYPD held a press conference regarding the fatal shooting of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson at 1 Police Plaza in New York City. At this conference the described the shooter as “a light-skinned male wearing a light brown or cream-colored jacket, a black face mask, black-and-white sneakers, and carrying a distinctive gray backpack”. (Source: TheHill)

    • NOTE: The description of a “light brown or cream-colored jacket” matches the original 911 call but not necessarily the images which indicate a dark gray or black jacket.

December 5, 2024 (Thursday)

  • Investigators believe a person of interest boarded a bus at the George Washington Bridge bus terminal, a person familiar with the matter told CBS News. Joseph Kenny, the NYPD’s chief of detectives, told reporters that investigators don’t know what bus the man may have taken. (Source: CBSNews)

  • The New York Police Department found a backpack in Central Park believed to have been the one carried by the suspect at the time of the shooting. Police said the backpack was being analyzed to determine if it belonged to the suspect. (Source: CBSNews)

    • NOTE: CBSNews reports that the backpack is found Thursday the 5th while ABCNews reports that it was found Friday, the 6th. Why the descrepency?

  • Investigators then received new footage of the suspect checking back into the Hostel where they say he had been staying the day after the shooting on the 5th. He allegedly was flirting with the desk clerk who asked him to show her his pretty smile so he lowered his mask for her which was caught on camera. (Source: Tubitv)

December 6, 2024 (Friday)

  • The official Complaint against Luigi Mangione documents that a backpack was found in Central Park on the 6th. (Source: Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione)

  • Days following the shooting: NYPD deploys extensive resources, including drones and scuba divers, to find evidence and track the suspect. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder,)

Kenny and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch reveal that investigators believe the gunman left New York City on a bus. Investigators say he entered the George Washington Bridge Bus Station but have not found video of him leaving or getting on a bus. (Source: APNews)

  • The FBI, which is also assisting the NYPD with the investigation, announced a $50,000 reward Friday night for information leading to an arrest in the case. (Source: CBSNews)

  • Friday after the shooting: Police find a backpack in Central Park containing a jacket and Monopoly money. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

    • NOTE: CBSNews reports that the backpack is found Thursday the 5th while ABCNews reports that it was found Friday, the 6th. Why the descrepency?

  • Police find what they say is the man’s backpack. Its contents are not disclosed. (Source: APNews)

  • The New York Post confirms that the suspect dropped the backpack full of monopoly money in Central Park (Source: Tubitv)

December 7, 2024 (Saturday)

  • Police continue to search Central Park; scuba divers are seen scouring a pond. The NYPD releases additional photos showing the suspected shooter next to and in the back seat of a taxi. In both images he is seen wearing a blue, medical-style face mask.

  • Despite recovering a fingerprint from the Starbucks purchase and sending items for DNA testing, police have yet to publicly identify the suspect.

  • Joe Marino, Senior Reporter for the New York Post indicates that a person was discovered three days after the shooting who was “almost a dead ringer” for the suspect seen in the photo surveillance cameras. However, it turned out he had an air-tight alibi and there was no way he could have been in New York at the time of the incident and law enforcement had to reverse course. (Source: Tubitv)

December 8, 2024 (Sunday)

  • Scuba divers are again seen at a Central Park pond. Police decline to comment on the investigation. (Source: APNews)

  • On Dec. 8, FBI agents and NYPD detectives spoke to Mangione’s mother after San Francisco police informed them she had filed a missing persons report and Mangione’s photo seemed to match the suspect photo, law enforcement sources told ABC News. (Source: ABCNews)

December 9, 2024

  • Sometime in the early morning of December 9, John Kuklis, a hotel clerk at the Horseshoe Curve Lodge in Altoona, Pennsylvania, reports having seen a man now believed to be Luigi Mangione asking for a room just hours before what would become his arrest. At the time no rooms were available and the suspect (who was wearing a mask) asked if he could wait in the lobby until the room comes available. The hotel clerk told him no and the suspect left. Allegedly he decided to kill some time at McDonalds where he would later be arrested. Law enforcement claim to have gone back to the hotel and checked video footage of this interaction at the hotel and confirm that the suspect was Luigi Mangione attempting to get a room hours before his arrest. (Source: PennLive.com)

  • A private funeral service was held for Brian Thompson on December 9, 2024, at a Lutheran church in Maple Grove, Minnesota, where family and friends gathered to pay their respects. (Source: Newsweek)

  • NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch identifies 26-year-old Luigi Nicholas Mangione as a person of interest in the case. (Source: CBSNews)

  • ~9:00 AM: A person walks into a local McDonalds in Altoona, Pennsyvania wearing a light tan knitted cap, dark jacket and carrying a backpack. He pulls his mask off his face and dangles it off his right ear literally “giving everyone a view of his face. (Source: Tubitv)

    • An older gentlemen notices the man and says to another older gentleman, “You know, I think that’s the guy their looking for in New York City”. A customer then tells a McDonald’s worker and the worker calls the cops.

  • 9:14 AM: A worker at a fast food restaurant in Altoona, Pennsylvania called the police about a male customer later identified as LUIGI NICHOLAS MANGIONE, the defendant, who the worker believed resembled photos of the Shooter that had been broadcast in the media following the Victim’s murder. Police in Altoona, Pennsylvania, are dispatched to investigate. (Source: APNews, Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione).

  • Two Altoona police approach the suspect and ask him to remove his mask and show ID. The suspect provides a New Jersey Driver’s License with the name Mark Rosaria, birthdate 07-21-1998. This, according to sources, is the same fake ID used at the hostel in New York. (Source: Tubitv)

    • According to the “Police Criminal Complained” by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (Incident number 2024-29133), the suspect had a silver laptop sitting on the table in front of him and a backpack.

    • According to the same complaint, the suspect was arrested and transported to the Altoona Police Department. It was there that, per policy, the “inventoried” his backpack and discovered the following items: A black 3D-printed pistol and black silencer and one loose 9mm hollow point round. The gun was described as having a metal slide and plastic handle with a metal threaded barrel. The gun had one magazine loaded with six 9mm full metal jacket rounds.

    • NOTE: There is NO mention in the complain or inventory of a notebook or a manifesto or of $8000 in US currency and $2000 in foreign currency as will later be revealed. This is MAJOR problem for me. How did these items NOT get listed in the complaint when listing the contents of the backpack or the items with him such as the laptop?

    • Later, on the 18th, the Federal government now adds additional items that were found on Luigi Mangione in Altoona Pennsyvlania and they now include: “clothing that matched apparel that the Shooter wore in the security camera videos”, a notebook, several thousand dollars in cash, an envelope associated with an FDIC-insured bank, and a letter addressed “To the Feds” (the “Feds Letter”). (Source: Complaint Southern District of New York: United States Luigi Nicholas Mangione).

    • NOTE: This HIGHLY suggests that the Federal government ADDED/PLANTED evidence among Luigi Mangione’s possessions while he was in custody of Altoona Police Department. The fact that the original listing of possessions said NOTHING about a notebook, envelop, or letter is HIGHLY suspicious. It is as if they wanted to ensure that Luigi was “found” with evidence that more directly ties him to the shooting in New York.

    • The Notebook they later claimed he had contained several handwritten pages that express hostility towards the health insurance industry and wealthy executives in particular. For example, the Notebook contained the following statements in entries that appear to correspond to particular dates:

      • In an entry marked as “8/15” [August 15, 2024], the Notebook described how “the details are finally coming together” and “I’m glad – in a way – that I’ve procrastinated, bc [because] it allowed me to learn more about [acronym for Company-1].” The Notebook entry also stated that “the target is insurance” because “it checks every box.”

      • In an entry marked as “10/22” [October 22, 2024], the Notebook stated: “1.5 months. This investor conference is a true windfall . . . and – most importantly – the message becomes self evident.” Later on in the entry, the Notebook describes an intent to “wack” the CEO of one of the insurance companies at its investor conference. As described above, October 22, 2024 was approximately 6 weeks before the date of the murder of the Victim, which occurred on the date of Company-1’s investor conference

      • The Feds Letter recovered from MANGIONE stated: “I wasn’t working with anyone. This was fairly trivial: Some elementary social engineering, basic CAD, a lot of patience.” Based on my own research, I believe that “CAD” refers to “computer-aided design.” The Feds Letter also stated: “P.S. you can check serial numbers to verify this is all self-funded. My own ATM withdrawals.”

  • When law enforcement asks if the suspect has been in New York lately the suspect allegedly “freaks out” and begins visibly shaking. They ask him to tell him his REAL name and he reports that it is Luigi Mangione. (Source: Tubitv)

  • Police in Altoona, Pennsylvania, went to a McDonald’s restaurant in response to reports of a male matching the description of the suspect, according to a police spokesman.

  • Mangione had a gun believed to be the one used in last Wednesday’s shooting, as well as writings suggesting “ill will toward corporate America,” Kenny said on Monday. He also had clothing and a mask similar to those worn by the shooter and a fraudulent New Jersey ID matching the one used to check into the Manhattan hostel, Kenny said. (Source: APNews).

  • The gun is described as a “plastic 3D printed gun” along with six 9mm bullets. He has a hollow point bullet described as what you use for “maximum carnage”.

  • The person, identified as Luigi Mangione, was arrested on firearms charges, New York Commissioner Tisch said. Police said he had a fake New Jersey ID card that matched the one used to check in at the New York City hostel. (Source: CBSNews)

  • 6 days after the shooting: Luigi Mangione is arrested in a McDonald’s in Altoona, Pennsylvania. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

    • Prior to his arrest, Mangione was on a Greyhound bus traveling through Altoona, sources said. When he got off the bus and walked into a McDonald’s, a witness recognized him from the images of the suspect circulated by police. (Source: ABCNews)

NOTE: The image above is taken from Brian O’Shae’s substack page and includes his personal highlighted sections. He also listed the source of this information which can be found here: https://static.foxnews.com/foxnews.com/content/uploads/2024/12/mangione12-9-24.pdf

  • Post-arrest: Luigi Mangione is identified as a 26-year-old from Maryland, with a privileged background and a degree in engineering from the University of Pennsylvania. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • Evidence found: Police find a 3D-printed gun and silencer, multiple IDs, and a notebook with notes on computer-aided design in Mangione’s possession. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • Public reaction: Social media erupts with both condemnation and support for Mangione, with some viewing him as a vigilante against the healthcare industry. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • 5:30 PM: Mangione appears in court for arraignment on charges in Pennsylvania. (Source: Fox9)

  • Legal proceedings: Mangione is indicted on murder in the first degree in furtherance of terrorism, facing federal charges with the possibility of the death penalty. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • Public opinion: The case sparks a debate on social media about the healthcare industry and vigilante justice, with some sympathizing with Mangione’s actions. (Source: ABC 20/20 Special, Manhunt: Luigi Mangione and the CEO Murder)

  • Luigi Mangione allegedly gave the arresting officers a fake name and fake ID. The fake name was Mark Rosario and the address was 128 Sherman Place (a location that does not exist). (Source: https://nj1015.com/murder-suspect-held-pennsylvania/?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

    • NOTE: Some have pointed out that this may be a clue pointing to the 1890 Sherman Antitrust Act which was passed to prohibit monopolies and to maintain competitive markets in the United States. Considering that a backpack full of Monopoly money was allegedly found in Central Park, it appears a VERY likely conclusion! They are leaving us clues!

    • It’s worth noting that “Mark Rosario” is also the name of a student affiliated with Princeton University’s Julis-Rabinowitz Center for Public Policy & Finance. However, there is no publicly available information linking this individual to Luigi Mangione or the events in question. (Source: https://nj1015.com/murder-suspect-held-pennsylvania/?utm_source=chatgpt.com)

    • NOTE: Luigi Mangione’s actual birthday is May 6, 1998. The birthday listed on the fake ID is July 21, 1998

December 10, 2024

  • Luigi Mangione, a suspect in the New York City killing of UnitedHealth executive Brian Thompson, arrives for an extradition hearing at Blair County Court House in Hollidaysburg, Pa., Dec. 10, 2024. (Source: ABCNews)

  • Mangione returns to court for a hearing on extradition. Ultimately, he waives extradition, meaning he will fight being moved. (Source: Fox9)

    • NOTE: Officially Luigi did NOT fight being moved.

  • Mangione appears to be represented by attorney Thomas Dickey who will defending him in the state charges brought against him. The exact date and manner in which Dickey was appointed is unclear. (Source: ABCNews)

  • Attorney Thomas Dickey, Altoona-based attorney, has been making the press rounds since he was retained to represent Mangione, including ABC News’ “Good Morning America” and CNN. He could not confirm how he came to represent Mangione; he would only say he was retained Tuesday ahead of the suspect’s extradition hearing in Pennsylvania. He said he “of course” knew of the New York case but said, “I don’t follow a lot of things sometimes in news.” (Source: ABCNews)

  • The court denied Mangione bail during the hearing. Mangione plans to challenge his extradition to New York. (Source: ABCNews)

    • “He has constitutional rights and that’s what he’s doing” in challenging the interstate transfer, Dickey told reporters on Tuesday. (Source: ABCNews)

  • The above image was plastered over the news and described in the Tubi special as a “Very satisfying image” for those against him him. (Source: Tubitv)

  • NOTE: This is likely because it takes the pretty, smiling, charming Luigi and paints him as a angry, rageful man full of hate.

December 11, 2024

  • Newsweek magazine reports that Luigi’s full manifesto has been been published online by independent journalist Ken Klippenstein visa his Substack blog and that it has “confirmed to be a legitimate transcription” by law enforcement authorities. (Source: Newsweek)

    • A transcription of the manifesto is available here (https://www.kenklippenstein.com/p/luigis-manifesto).

    • Ken Klippenstien insists this is the real manifesto and not the fake one circulating online. He also states that media outlines including the New York Times, The Washington Post, CNN and NBC have this as well and refuse to publish it even though the quote from it selectively. He has reached out to them to explain why but they refuse to answer. (https://www.kenklippenstein.com/p/luigis-manifesto).

    • The “manifesto” is claimed to be written by hand and states, among other things, that Luigi Mangione acted alone. (Source: Newsweek). Specifically a line reads: “To the Feds, I’ll keep this short, because I do respect what you do for our country. To save you a lengthy investigation, I state plainly that I wasn’t working with anyone.

    • Another line of note alleged to be written by Luigi Mangione is “Frankly, these parasites simply had it coming. A reminder: the US has the #1 most expensive healthcare system in the world, yet we rank roughly #42 in life expectancy.” (Source: Newsweek)

    • Newsweek confirmed that this “manifesto” was on Luigi at the time of his arrest in Altoona, Pennsylvania.

  • An interview conducted by News Nation from outside of the prison where Luigi Mangione is being detained in Hannington, Pennsylvania showed prisoners inside the prison shouting out the windows as reporters giving them updates on Luigi. One prison shouts that Luigi’s prison conditions suck and “Free Luigi!!” (Source: Tubitv)

December 13, 2024

  • Karen Friedman Agnifilo, former prosecutor at the Manhatten District Attorney’s Office and former legal analyst for CNN is retained by Mangione to represent him in his STATE case (State of New York vs. Luigi Mangione), replacing former attorney Thomas Dickey. Karen’s husband, Marc Agnifilo is also representing Mangione. The married couple are partners of Agnifilo Intrater LLP and are known for handling high-profile cases. (Source: Wikipedia and BusinessInsider.com)

  • Another super interesting note is that Marc Agnifilo is the lead attorney defending Sean “P Diddy” Combs who is being held in the same detention center as Luigi Mangione.

  • It is rumored that Marc will be assisting his wife as special counsel.

December 17, 2024

  • On Dec. 17, the Manhattan district attorney announced new charges against Mangione, including first-degree murder in furtherance of terrorism. This is the state of New York case which differs from the Federal case against Luigi Mangione.

    • He is also charged in New York with: two counts of second-degree murder, one of which is charged as killing as an act of terrorism; two counts of criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree; four counts of criminal possession of a weapon in the third degree; one count of criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree; and one count of criminal possession of a forged instrument in the second degree. (Source: ABCNews)

  • Mangione remains in the custody of the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections pending his extradition to New York. (Source: ABCNews)

December 18, 2024

  • The Federal Complaint against Luigi Mangione was filed December 18th.

December 19, 2024

  • Luigi Mangione is arrested by the Federal government.

  • Luigi Mangione receives unprecedented “perp walk” and is met by Mayor Eric Adams in widely televised spectacle. He was flown into New York by helicopter and met by a massive police presence, media and a crowd of supporters. There were multiple law enforcement agencies on site including New York City and New York County Departments of Justice, various other law enforcement officials from multiple agencies, and the Mayor of New York City, Mayor Eric Adams

  • Luigi Mangione’s attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo arrives at the Daniel Patrick Moynihan Courthouse in Manhattan, New York, on December 19, 2024. She was seen using crutches to assist her mobility. She had arrived on crutches, having torn an ACL.  (Source: The Daily Beast and AOL).

  • 1:00 PM: The Agnifilos (Karen and Marc) had expected to appear with their client, Luigi Mangione a block away, in STATE court, for a 2 p.m. arraignment on a grand jury indictment for murder and terrorism. But at 1 p.m., Mangione was arrested by the Federal government and immediately hauled into federal court, where a grand jury had yet to hear the case. He was brought into courtroom 26a to appear before Magistrate Judge Katharine H. Parker on a criminal complaint sworn to by an FBI agent.

  • The clerk then announced the case that the feds had stepped in to grab first.

    • “24 MAG 4357. U.S. versus MANGIONE.”

    • Among other things, the FBI agent bring the arrest warrant to court alleged that along with a handgun and a silencer, Mangione had been carrying at the time of his arrest a handwritten letter addressed, “To the Feds.” The feds had now responded with the complaint, a copy of which appeared to be on the defense table. (Source: The Daily Beast ).

      • The most serious of the listed charges is a violation of United States Code Section 1111(a), murder with the use of a firearm. The major difference from the top state charge is the penalty. New York State does not allow capital punishment. “Death penalty eligible,” is how Friedman Agnifilo described the top federal charge. (Source: The Daily Beast ).

  • The judge asked Luigi’s counsel if he was requesting bail and Karen Agnifilo responded “not at this time”. (Source: The Daily Beast ).

  • It came out today that the state case against Mangioni will precede the Federal case. (Source: The Daily Beast ).

  • By the end of Thursday’s federal proceeding, no date and time had been set for arraignment on the state charges.

  • Outside the courtroom Karen Agnifilo spoke to the press about this unexpected carting away of her client. “All of a sudden we are here,” Friedman Agnifilo said, noting that in 30 years practicing criminal law, “frankly, I’ve never seen anything like this.” (Source: The Daily Beast ).

  • The Federal Judge presiding over the Federal case against Mangione is Judge Katharine H. Parker.

    • Katharine Parker’s husband, Bret Parker was an executive of Pfizer where he was the vice president and assistant general counsel in 2010. (Source: Newsweek)

    • The judge also holds hundreds of thousands of dollars in stock including Pfizer and other health-care and pharmaceutical companies according to her 2023 financial disclosure. (Source: Newsweek)

    • Parker holds between $50,000 and $100,000 in Pfizer stock and her husband still draws a pension from Pfizer. (Source: Newsweek)

    • Bret Parker is currently the executive director of the New York City Bar Association since 2013. (Source: Newsweek)

    • The Judge’s ties with the health-care industry raises concerns about a potential conflict of interest. (Source: Newsweek)

    • While Katharine Parker is presiding over the pretrial hearings, she is not expected to oversee the actual trial (Source: Newsweek)

December 23, 2024

  • On December 23, 2024, during a court appearance, attorney Karen Friedman Agnifilo criticized the highly publicized “perp walk” of her client, Luigi Mangione. She described it as “the biggest staged perp walk I’ve ever seen in my career” and deemed it “absolutely unnecessary.” Friedman Agnifilo specifically criticized New York City Mayor Eric Adams for participating in the event, suggesting that his involvement was politically motivated and could prejudice Mangione’s right to a fair trial. She remarked, “The mayor should know more than anyone about the presumption of innocence.” (Source: Yahoo)

  • The “perp walk” in question occurred on December 19, 2024, when Mangione was extradited from Pennsylvania to New York. He was escorted by a large contingent of law enforcement officers, including Mayor Adams, in a highly publicized event. Friedman Agnifilo argued that such displays are unconstitutional when unrelated to legitimate law enforcement objectives and serve only to create a spectacle that undermines the presumption of innocence.

  • Luigi Mangione plead not guilty to 11 charges brought by the state of New York including first-degree murder, two variations of second-degree murder, and weapons charges.

December 28, 2024

  • Videos on YouTube by “Real Nathan Daely” claim that UnitedHealthCare is an insurance provider for the State of New York, specifically for police officers. (Source: Real Nathan Daley)

    • UnitedHealthCare also sponsors and donates millions of dollars to police funds. (Source: Real Nathan Daley)

    • NOTE: This might suggest that New York Law Enforcement may have a vested interested in making Luigi Mangione look guilty even if he is not.

December 30, 2024

  • UnitedHealth Group is on track to achieve record financial results by the end of this year. CEO Andrew Witty has privately informed executives that the company expects to surpass previous financial milestones, with revenues exceeding $299 billion through September, up from $277 billion last year. (Source: New York Post)

2025

January

January 2, 2025

  • The New York Post released a documentary on Luigi titled “New York Post Presents: Luigi Mangione Monster or Martyr?” (Source: NYPost)

    • The documentary frequently, and without evidence, keeps asking questions about his mental health issues and speculating about his mental health diagnosis. (Source: Tubitv)

    • The documentary spends considerable time discussing his “GoodReads” account and his praise for the Unibomber among other things. Of particular note they point out his quoted the book “When all other forms of communication fail, violence is necessary to survive. as well as the statement “it’s not terrorism, it’s war and revolution.”(Source: TubiTV)

    • The documentary revealed that the Mangione family trust is worth more than $4 Million dollars and their house alone is more than $2 Million dollars. (Source: Tubitv)

January 18, 2025

  • Luigi Mangione’s next federal court appearance is scheduled for January 18, 2025. (Source: ABCNews)

February

February 4, 2025

  • Luigi Mangione’s defense team adds Avi Moskowitz to his defense team. Avi is an expert in capital cases and the death penalty. (Source: ABCNews)

February 17, 2025

  • Luigi Mangione WAS expected to be indicted for murder by a grand jury by the 17th paving the way for the federal case to proceed. This date has been postponed to March 19, 2025 (Source: WHYY PBS, USCourts.gov)

  • A new Documentary about Luigi Mangione aired on HBO and Investigation Discovery titled “Who is Luigi Mangione?”

February 21, 2025

  • Luigi Mangione is set to appear in New York State court (state case) on February 21, 2025 regarding the state charges. (Source: Independent)

February 24, 2025

  • Luigi is scheduled for a preliminary hearing in the Pennsylvania state court, at 8:00 AM.

  • We believe it was at this hearing that Luigi’s attorney, Thomas Dickey filed an “Omnibus Pretrial Motion for Relief” in relation to the arrest of Luigi Mangione in Altoona, PA. In the motion, Dickey explains how the arresting officers illegally detained Luigi Mangione by forming a human wall preventing his exit from the corner where he was having breakfast and questioned him for at least 18 minutes during which they asked him to put his hands on his head and took his possessions from him and performed a pat down search. All of this was done without telling Luigi why he was being detained and without reading him his Miranda rights. Thomas Dickey moves therefore that the detention and confiscation of Luigi’s property and search of his belongings were illegal and without a warrant. At no time was Luigi made aware that he could leave or could deny the officer’s requests. A copy of the motion can be found here. (Source: The National News Desk)

March

March 1, 2025

  • The defendants in a lawsuit filed by the Hollywood Fire pension fund including CEO of UnitedHealth Group, Andrew Witty are expected to respond to the complaint by March 1, 2025. Brian Thompson was also expected to respond but obviously will not following his murder December 4, 2024

March 19, 2025

  • The date of the preliminary hearing or indictment in the case of United States vs Mangione (federal case), against Luigi Mangione has been scheduled for March 19, 2025. (SOURCE: USCourts.gov)

June

June 26, 2025